Return on ad spend is the most widely used performance metric in Google Ads. It's also one of the most misleading ways to measure whether your advertising is actually working for your business.
This isn't an argument against measuring efficiency. It's an argument for measuring the right kind of efficiency. ROAS tells you how much revenue you generated per dollar of ad spend. What it doesn't tell you is whether that revenue was profitable, or whether you'd have been better off not spending that money at all.
Why ROAS lies about profitability
Say your campaign generates £10 for every £1 spent — a 10x ROAS. Sounds excellent. But if your product costs £7 to make and deliver, you've kept £3 in gross margin. Take out the £1 in ad spend, and you've made £2 per sale. Now factor in overheads, fulfilment complexity, return rates, and customer service cost — and that "impressive" 10x ROAS might be breaking even at best.
The problem compounds when you have a mixed product catalogue. A high-margin product and a low-margin product can both return a 10x ROAS, but the profitability of selling one versus the other is completely different. ROAS treats both sales as equivalent. Your P&L doesn't.
What to use instead: contribution margin
The metric that actually matters is contribution margin — revenue minus variable costs (product cost, fulfilment, payment processing, returns). This tells you what's left over to cover fixed costs and generate actual profit.
Once you know your contribution margin, you can calculate a target ROAS that makes sense:
Target ROAS = 1 / (contribution margin %)
So if your average contribution margin is 40%, your break-even ROAS is 1 / 0.40 = 2.5x. You need to beat 2.5x just to cover the cost of the product. If your ROAS target in Google Ads is 4x, you're targeting a contribution margin after ad spend of about 15% of revenue — which may or may not be enough, depending on your fixed cost structure.
This is a simplification, but it gives you a grounded starting point that's rooted in your actual business economics rather than an arbitrary benchmark.
The product mix problem
The more sophisticated version of this problem involves variable margins across your product catalogue. Most eCommerce businesses don't have uniform margins. Your hero SKU might contribute 55% margin; your promotional bundle might contribute 18%. Advertising both at the same ROAS target makes no sense.
The fix is to segment your campaigns or ad groups by margin tier — typically through custom labels in your Shopping feed — and set different ROAS targets for each. High-margin products can sustain a lower ROAS target (you're comfortable paying more for each sale because each sale is worth more). Low-margin products need a higher ROAS target or shouldn't be advertised at all.
This is one of the most impactful structural changes you can make in a Shopping or PMax account. Most brands don't do it because it requires knowing your margins by product, which means the finance team needs to be involved. But the reward is significant: you stop subsidising low-margin sales with your ad budget and start concentrating spend on the products that actually move your P&L.
How to actually implement this
- Get your contribution margin data by product or category from your finance team — or calculate it from your Shopify/WooCommerce reports combined with COGS data
- Group products into two or three margin tiers (high, medium, low)
- Create custom labels in your Google Merchant Center feed to tag each product with its margin tier
- Structure your Shopping or PMax asset groups to separate these tiers
- Set ROAS targets for each tier based on your margin calculation, with a buffer for overhead contribution
You don't need perfect margin data to start. Rough tiers — your highest-margin product categories versus your lowest — will immediately improve the quality of your budget allocation decisions.
A note on new customer acquisition
One more dimension that pure ROAS measurement misses: customer lifetime value. If you're acquiring new customers who go on to purchase repeatedly, the ROAS of that first conversion dramatically understates the true return. This is why some brands deliberately accept lower ROAS for campaigns targeting new customer acquisition versus campaigns serving existing demand.
There's no one-size-fits-all answer here. But it's another reason to understand your business economics deeply before setting performance targets in your ad platform — because the targets you set directly shape where Google's algorithms spend your money.